Skip to content
Big enough to win, small enough to care
Pay Online  | Call Us Today 1-715-344-0890
Anderson O'Brien, LLP Logo
  • About Our Firm
    • History
    • News
    • Newsletter
    • Careers
    • Central Wisconsin Community Involvement
    • Walk for Hope 2025
  • Practice Areas
    • Accident & Personal Injury
      • Car Accidents
      • Motorcycle Accidents
      • Traumatic Brain Injuries
      • Pedestrian Accidents
      • Bicycle Accidents
      • Wrongful Death
    • Business & Corporate Law
    • Divorce & Family Law
    • Divorce Mediation
    • Elder Law & Guardianship
    • Employment & Labor Law
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Municipal Law
    • Nursing Home Planning
    • Probate & Trust Settlements
    • Real Estate
    • Tax Planning
    • Wills, Trusts & Estate Planning
    • Workers’ Compensation
  • Areas We Serve
    • Stevens Point
    • Wisconsin Rapids
    • Marshfield
    • Portage County
    • Wood County
    • Waushara County
    • Wausau
    • Marathon County
  • Attorneys
  • Blog
  • Seminars
  • Search
Contact Us

Who Pays Medical Bills Before a Settlement?

Home  >  Blog Articles  >  Who Pays Medical Bills Before a Settlement?

April 22, 2019 | By Attorney Brent W. Jacobson
Who Pays Medical Bills Before a Settlement?

If you are involved in a motor vehicle accident, you probably have many questions, including questions about how your medical bills will be paid. If you were injured in a motor vehicle accident due to the negligence of another person, you may recover your medical bills through a lawsuit. However, it may be months or even years before you receive a settlement or judgment from the negligent driver and his or her insurance company. In the meantime, you need to ensure that your medical bills are covered. How those bills are paid will ultimately affect your recovery.

The first place you will want to look for insurance coverage for medical bills is your own automobile policy. Many drivers are unaware that their automobile policy may carry a certain amount of coverage for medical bills arising from an automobile accident. This amount is usually minimal, but every bit helps. If you reach a settlement with the negligent driver’s insurer, your automobile insurer generally is not entitled to be refunded for the medical bills it paid unless and until you are made whole by the settlement – meaning that you are fully compensated for all elements of damage. In most cases, a negotiated reduction is reached to avoid a separate mini-trial on this issue.

The next place you will want to look for medical coverage is your own health insurance. If you have health insurance through an employer-sponsored plan that is fully-funded by the employer, you may have to pay that health plan back all of the amount it paid for your medical bills regardless of whether you are made whole. These plans, referred to as self-funded ERISA plans, are governed by federal law, which preempts state law concepts such as the made whole doctrine. Some of these plans, however, are insured by a third party. An experienced lawyer will know to research the plan to determine whether it is insured or self-funded and whether arguments can be made in an effort to reduce the amount you are required to refund the plan from your settlement.

Finally, if you are insured through Medicare, the federal government has established a specific formula to calculate the amount that must be refunded. That formula is based on the amount of the settlement or judgment and the amount of legal fees and costs associated with achieving it.

Before resolving any case, it is always important to know what your payback obligations are to third parties that paid for medical bills related to the accident. Having an experienced lawyer involved gives you the benefit of determining what these payback obligations are and how to negotiate reductions where possible to account for the time and effort you and your counsel spent to recover from the negligent party.

Are you looking for legal advice?

Let one of our experienced attorneys assist you today.

Contact Us
  • Stevens Point Bus Accident
  • Stevens Point Hit & Run Accident
  • Stevens Point Workers' Compensation
  • Stevens Point Accident and Personal Injury
  • Stevens Point, Wisconsin Wrongful Death Lawyer
  • Stevens Point, Wisconsin Traumatic Brain Injury Lawyer
  • Stevens Point, Wisconsin Drunk Driving Accident Lawyer
  • Stevens Point, Wisconsin Car Accident Lawyer
  • Stevens Point Wisconsin Motorcycle Accident Lawyer
  • Stevens Point, Wisconsin Bicycle Accident Lawyer

Table Of Contents

Excellence in law. Dedication to our community.

Let’s Get In Touch

Are you looking for legal advice? Let one of our experienced attorneys assist you today.

Contact Us

Anderson Law Full Group

Anderson O'Brien, LLP Logo
1257 Main Street,
Stevens Point, WI 54481
1-715-344-0890 info@andlaw.com Business Hours:
8 a.m. - 5 p.m. Monday - Thursday
8 a.m. - 4 p.m. Fridays
  • Pay Online
  • Seminars
  • Newsletter
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap

Connect With Us

Anderson O’Brien, LLP has a team of exceptional attorneys who concentrate in one or more areas of the law. Our ability to utilize the expertise of each of our attorneys for the benefit of our clients is what sets us apart and makes us unique in central Wisconsin. Excellence in law. Dedication to our community.

© 2026 Anderson O'Brien, LLP | All rights reserved.